Pittsburgh Hockey Insider has no direct affiliation to the Pittsburgh Penguins, NHL or NHLPA

Kyle Dubas recalling Jack St. Ivany proves the Penguins needed better puck movement on defense


PUBLICATION
Daniel Lucente
March 16, 2026  (2:39 PM)
SHARE THIS STORY

Pittsburgh Penguins defenseman Jack St. Ivany (3) and goaltender Arturs Silovs (37) defend a shot by Tampa Bay Lightning center Jake Guentzel (59) during the second period at PPG Paints Arena.
Photo credit: Charles LeClaire-Imagn Images

The Pittsburgh Penguins are forcing a shift in identity before the schedule turns punishing.

By swapping a former first-round pick for a specialized puck-mover, Kyle Dubas is signaling that "safe" hockey is no longer an option for this blue line.
While the cap hit remains identical, the decision to abruptly swap defensive assets suggests an intense internal battle to fix a "hidden" transition flaw before the schedule turns punishing.
The official team account reported it first. St. Ivany, 26, is back from a conditioning loan after hand surgery, and the 2018 fourth-round Flyers pick is signed through 2026-27 at a $775,000 cap hit.
Alexeyev, 26, the 2018 first-round Capitals pick, heads to Wilkes-Barre on his expiring $775,000 deal, which still leaves him RFA-controlled after this season.
This is the part that matters on the ice. Pittsburgh gets back a right-shot defender who moved pucks cleanly before getting hurt.
St. Ivany posted 0-7-7 in 17 NHL games before the January 27 surgery, then put up 1-5-6 in seven AHL games on the tune-up.
That profile fits what Pittsburgh needs more than pure reach. Breakouts have to be faster when the next game is Monday against Colorado.
Alexeyev still has value as depth size on the left side. But his 3-4-7 in 29 AHL games has not pushed him past St. Ivany in the puck-moving pecking order.

A strategic gamble on mobility over safety for the stretch run

Penguins fans will look at this and see a minor paper move, but it feels like a coach's bet on cleaner exits over safer glass-outs.
The cap side is clean. This is a like-for-like shuffle, so Kyle Dubas upgrades stylistic fit without adding fresh cap stress.
That is why this transaction reads bigger than the headline.
St. Ivany is not here to run the man advantage. He is here to help a third pair survive forecheck heat and get the puck to Pittsburgh's top-six faster.
His January sample already showed the template. Seven assists in 17 games from a depth defender is support offense this roster can use right now.
So yes, this is a recall. It is also a quiet deadline-style clue about what Pittsburgh trusts when games tighten.
POLL
MARS 16|105 ANSWERS
Kyle Dubas recalling Jack St. Ivany proves the Penguins needed better puck movement on defense

Should Jack St. Ivany stay in the Pittsburgh Penguins lineup after this recall?

Yes8984.8 %
No1615.2 %
List of polls

HOCKEYUNPLUGGED
COPYRIGHT @2026 - ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.
TERMS OF SERVICE - PRIVACY POLICY - COOKIE POLICY
RSS FEED - SITEMAP - ROBOTS.TXT